SMBOttawa 4 Recap


The fourth Social Media Breakfast (SMB) Ottawa, held today at Gowlings, had a huge turnout. I’m thinking the topic of online communities is definitely a hot topic for the city.

The SMB Ottawa founders (Rob Lane, Ryan Anderson and Simon Chen) organized a panel of online community experts in the city.

  • Luc Levesque, Founder & General Manager, TravelPod (A TripAdvisor / Expedia Company)
  • Gérard Métrailler, Senior Director, Product Management, Graphics, Corel Corporation
  • Ian Skerrett, Director of Marketing, Eclipse Foundation
  • With Jens Evans, Founder and Chief Strategist, Sequentia Evironics (Toronto) as the panel moderator

Their expertise comes from actually implementing online communities for B2B and B2C engagement.

Jen presented various statements about online community and social media engagement, of which the panelists had the opportunity to agree or disagree. The audience chimed in with their own view points which was fantastic.

Without further ado, here is a quick run-down of the panel discussion…

60% to 70% of any community are lurkers and won’t actively engage (post comments or contribute content)

  • Had a 50/50 split on audience agreement with this number
  • Ian – don’t fret about it since you will have a core group who will contribute and carry community engagement. The number will build over time

A blog is a community

  • Gerard – in isolation, no. But as part of a collection of blogs that share common interests, yes.
  • Ian – blog is a tool to build community but not a community in itself

According to Gartner Research, 50% of soical media and community programs in Fortune 1000 companies will fail by 2010

  • Luc – by not incorporating community measurement into programs, your initiative will fail. You need to understand the value social media / online community can bring to your business (and your customers)
  • Gerard – thinks 50% is low and the number is probably higher

Most important characteristic of a community is vibrancy (activity, engagement), etc

  • Ian – important to give your audience something to talk about and do this regularly to bring fresh content to the community
  • Luc – spur conversations to turn lurkers into participants
  • 70% agreement from the audience with this statement

Makes no business sense to give competitors access to your community conversations. Closed communities are the way to go.

  • Gerard – Corel builds open communities except for the beta community. Once product is releases, the community opens because Corel wants to capture product conversations on their own communities versus trying to find them elsewhere on the web
  • Luc – depends on the situation – sometimes it makes sense to have a closed community
  • Ian – to grow your community, it needs to be open otherwise it can be hard to build buy-in. It also depends on your audience and objective

Search and ongoing member acquisition is critical to health of any community

  • Luc – absolutely essential. Measure through the number of people coming in and how engaged they are. Use search marketing to feed community content into search engines as way to grow awareness
  • Ian – new and acquired member engagement is equally important. Need to look at diversity of your membership base (geography, age, expertise, etc)
  • Gerard – Corel uses a combination of organic and paid search marketing to build community growth. Work with evangelists to welcome new members and encourage them to interact.

Building successful communities is a full-time strategic endeavour and requires a team, thought and planning

  • Ian – adhere to certain best practices: have relevent content, have a visible community leader (ambassador) who champions the community, make it easy to join, involve the whole organization
  • Luc – need to know your community objective and you need someone to administer the community. Your company needs to be involved (engaging members and contributing content) to demonstrate commitment.
  • Gerard – Corel is a customer-driven company and sees community as one way to focus on customer needs

Online community and social media programs will be a casualty as businesses seek to pare down costs during current economic crunch

  • Gerard – once your community hits a critical mass, it can be self-sustaining and require little economic investment.
  • Luc – if your community or social media engagement can’t be measures, expect it to be affected. Don’t look at revenue ROIs as the necessary pull-plug factor. Look at other key performance indicators such as decrease in support calls (and therefore decrease in support costs)
  • Ian – often can be less expensive than traditional marketing initiatives. Ensure your community offers value to members to ensure its longevity
  • Audience felt communities are mission critical to corporate objectives and thus won’t be a casualty

Blogs start every 1.4 seconds. The only way to stand out in the clamour for attention is to focus and go niche

  • Ian – it’s marketing 101 – have an objective and purpose and a target audience
  • Luc – have to have good product and/or good makreting
  • Gerard – focus on a niche – know your audience and the value you deliver

During Q&A there were lots of questions around social media metrics…

  • Gerard – track where people are coming from using traditional analytics tools but to track what people are doing in the community, you’ll need to either find a platform that offers this analysis natively, find a community analytics tool or build one in-house
  • Ian – a good place to start is to look at trends in downloads from the community. Track the people who contributing value (number of people and what they are contributing). Find out how they found and then joined the community to get your conversion metric

And that’s my recap in a nutshell! For another perspective on SMB Ottawa 4, check out Joe Boughner’s post at If you’ve come across other reviews/recaps of the event, please share them via the comments section below

On a related note – my first video blog interviews…

After the event, Simon Chen and I sat down with Jen Evans to discuss Sequentia-Environics’ role in helping companies implement their community engagement.

I also had an opportunity to chat with Kelly Rusk of and SmartHippo about how she entered into the social media scene and was able to eventually built herself a career out of it.

Look for my first ever video blog postings on these two interviews in the near future.

8 Responses to “SMBOttawa 4 Recap”

  1. Kelly

    Great recap Mel! And I’m looking forward to seeing the video!

  2. Amanda

    Thanks for the recap Mel. Very helpful that you captured the panelists’ individual viewpoints on each question. I’ll be passing this along to others who were also in attendance.

  3. Wendy

    SMB was a great start to my day. Inspired a deep dig into the metrics to analyse my traffic and the types of participation from various marketing channels.

    Thanks for the great recap Mel, and to again to everyone who organised this excellent event.

  4. Social Media Breakfast Ottawa #4 » Home Business Blog

    […] For further details on the panel and the event please visit the Eventbrite page. Mel Gallant also wrote a great detailed recap here. […]

  5. Bloggeries

    Great recap Mel; I linked to it in my recap as you definitely took more notes than myself.

    Looking forward to seeing everyone at SMBOttawa #5.

  6. melgallant

    Thanks everyone. See you at the next SMB Ottawa event in December!

  7. Checking out - and loving - the scene — by Amanda Shiga

    […] great re-cap of the event and discussion can be found here, courtesy of Mel Gallant. digg_skin = […]

  8. C. Carteaux

    It sounds like a productive time was had by all, thanks for the in-depth recap!

    C. Carteaux


Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge